Joshua's first letter to Mrs. Szymanski |
November 15, 2000
Hi Mrs. Lois,
I am 8. I like to sing. I would like to write a
story about Cats. My cat is 1. It is black and
white and brown. I have been to Oakacoke. It is a
beach. I like
it. Is very fun there.
Your Friend,
Joshua
November 20, 2000
Hi there Joshua,
It was good to get your letter. I see you like to sing. My daughter loved to sing when she was your
age and she still does. Now she has a CD out and is singing with her own band every week. If you
love to do something it can stay in your life forever. Maybe you can have a main character in your
story who likes to sing? That might give your story an extra special something that is you!
I love cats, too! I have two cats. A big fat buff colored cat called Dusty, and a small, but naughty
black cat named Zachary. Your cat is very special because he has three colors! I bet your cat is
pretty! Do you want to write a story about your cat, or one with your cat in it?
I bet Ocracoke was a neat island to visit! I have read a lot about it and it seems it is very much like
Assateague Island, the island I like to write about. Both islands have wild ponies! Both islands are
barrier islands. That means they protect land the inland (which is actually below sea level), from the
ocean waves and winds. Also, both Assateague and Ocracoke have historic lighthouses and a marsh
land setting. But Ocracoke has the mysterious tales of how Blackbeard, the legendary pirate, once
roamed there! What an exciting place. Is this a setting where you might like your story to take
place?
Think about all the things in your life, all the things you like to do, the places you've been, and the
stories you like to read and it will help you decide what to write your story about. You will need a
setting. That is where your story takes place. And you will need an idea of what to write about, and
you will need some characters, (people, animals, or made up creatures) to be in your story.
Think hard about the things in your life. Authors are always told to write what they know about.
When you write about something you know about it comes from experience, and from life, and from
the heart, and your writing is always better.
When you have decided what you will write about, you can play the What-if Game.
That's when you create lots of different ways the story can go by asking yourself, what if this
happened, or what if that happened. Your story can go in many different directions, but which way it
goes will depend on what you choose from your What-if game.
Whatever you do, remember to make your story fun to write. Writing stories should always be fun! I
will help you with the hard parts, and you have fun with the other parts!
I am looking forward to seeing your story!
Your Friend,
Lois Szymanski
Joshua's second letter to Mrs. Szymanski |
Dear Mrs. Szymanski,
Thank you for my letter. I love my cats. I want my story to be about cats.
My cat is playful. One of my cats is three colors. Her name is Angel and
she is a calico cat. My other cat is a boy. His name is Zero. He's special
because he has an "0" on his side. Both of my cats are good. My cats make
me laugh. Angel likes to mess with your feet. She sleeps with me and when
I move my feet she prounces on them. Angel watches TV.
I want the setting to be in my house. The main characters in my story will
be Angel and Zero.
Your friend,
Joshua
Mrs. Szymanski's second letter to Joshua |
Hello Joshua,
I was so impressed when I read your letter. You already know what you will
write about and who your characters will be. It sounds like a great idea to
start with, and you have the added bonus of knowing your characters very
well! That helps with description and knowing what to write about.
Your cats sound so nice. Angel sounds like the playful one, but Zero has
that special mark on his side. I have never seen a cat with a number on
his side!
Now that you know what you will write about, your characters, and your
setting, you
will have to come up with a plot. The plot is what actually happens in the
story. To
help you develop your story remember these things:
- Every good story starts with a hook, a problem, or a mystery, or a
question that
draws the readers in and makes them want to read more. Sometimes the question
is as simple as making the reader ask, "Oh, my, what will this character do
next?"
- The middle of the story helps the reader get to know the main character
better as
the plot of the story unfolds. It adds some details and sometimes action or
humor.
- The end of the story is called the conclusion. It solves the problem or
mystery, or
answers the question from the beginnng and makes the reader feel satisfied.
I like to read cat stories and you already have me curious about what will
happen in
your story. I hope you have fun developing the plot, and I will look
forward to your
next letter!
Your Friend,
Lois Szymanski
P.S. Have you ever read the book "Diary of a Cat"? It is very funny!
Joshua's third letter to Mrs. Szymanski |
Dear Mrs. Szymanski,
My story setting is in my mom's room. The main characters are mom, Zero
and Angel. The hook for my story is mom's jewelry is missing.
"Oh no! It's gone!" My mom was getting ready for church when she
discovered that her cross necklace was missing. She opened her jewelry box
and her favorite neckiace was not there. She look through the house. She
found the cats in the closet. She thought that a brid flew in the window and
took it. She found Angel under her bed and then she saw the necklace. Then
she knew that the cats did it.
Your friend,
Joshua Messick
HI Joshua,
You have begun writing a very exciting mystery story!
I love mysteries, and your first draft is very good.
The first draft of a story should give us a good feeling of
who the main characters are, the setting, and what the
story is about. Then you get to flesh it out. That means
to add more details, description, action and talking (dialogue).
When you flesh out your story, maybe you could think about
some of these ideas:
- I know that Zero and Angel are cats because you told me before
I read your story. Could you let the reader know they are cats? Adding
some description would be a great way to let us know they are kitties.
I am wondering what they look like, and if they are playful, or lazy, silly
or bad, or very good. It sounds like they might be mischievious! Maybe you
could have one of the kitties running with something in their mouth, or chasing
something, to show that they like to play with things in the house?
- What made mom think a bird could have taken it? Is there a bird that hangs
around outside her bedroom window a lot? I thought a thief could have taken it.
- You could add more suspense by having mom look several places before she
finds out the cats have her necklace. This is where you could play the What If? game.
You could ask yourself, What if Mom looked here, and What if Mom looked there? What
would she find? Also, What if someone borrowed it and Mom forgot? What if a thief came
in the house? (It would be really scary if they thought there might be a thief in the neighborhood.)
You could ask yourself all kinds of what if questions, and then only use the things you
think would make the story better.
- You can add some description, too. What does your house look like? What does your
mom look like, and of course, those silly cats!
You story has such a great start. Your hook is excellent. You could really make someone
wonder what happened to the jewelry. I love your opening line, too. You started right in the
middle of the action, and with someone saying something that grabs the readers' attention.
That is a great way to start a story! I can't wait to see what happens when you flesh your
story out.
Have fun with your writing! I can't wait to see what you will write next!
Your Friend,
Lois Szymanski
Dear Mrs. Szymanski,
Here is my rough draft.
Mom's Lost Necklace
"Oh no! It's gone!" My mom was getting ready for church when she
discovered that her cross necklace was missing. She opened her jewelry box
and her favorite necklace was not in its special place where she always
kept it. She looked everywhere through the house. She looked through her
bathroom but it wasn't there. Then she looked in the closet where she hangs
her clothes. She found the cats in the closet.
Angel and Zero were naughty little cats. They were tearing up her dresses.
When they saw mom they both ran out of the closet. Angel had a piece of
ribbon in her mouth. Zero had a piece of leather from mom's shoe in his
mouth. Mom wasn't very happy.
Mom asked dad if he had seen it and dad said, "No, I did not touch it " Mom
was sad. Then mom asked me if I had seen it. I said I did not see it. Mom
was even sadder. She thought that a bird flew in the window and took it
because it was not anywhere to be found. She heard a sound in her room. It
sounded like a bell. She wondered where the sound came from. She found
Angel, the cat, under her bed and then she saw the necklace. Then she knew
that the cats did it. Mom was very happy she put her necklace.
Your friend,
Joshua Messick
3/19
Hi Josh,
It was good to hear from you! Are you enjoying the bits
of sunshine we've been getting lately? I think Spring is
thinking about sneaking in. I sure hope so!
I like your story a lot, and I only have a three little
suggestions for you today. I think it is great how
you are still opening your story with Mom speaking.
We immediately know that she is in distress and we
want to know what is wrong. That is a great way to
make a reader want to keep reading your story! And it's
good that you keep the mystery going with Mom asking
questions and worrying about who took the necklace. I
also like that two ornery cats are the theives! It
makes the reader smile at the end of the story.
Here are my picky suggestions for you:
- Pick places to break your story into more
paragraphs. I think you could make a new paragraph
just after mom opens the closet. You could start the new
paragraph with - Angel and Zero, two naughty little cats were
in the closet.
The next place you could have a paragraph break is when
Mom asks Dad if he has seen her necklace. As a rule, you
should start a new paragraph whenever the subject changes,
or someone new is speaking. So, also make a new paragraph
when she asks you if you've seen the necklace.
Start another paragraph when Mom
starts to think about her necklace and thinks
a bird could have gotten it, and start
one more where Mom hears a sound.
- Writers use something called Transition Lines to move
around in the story. Some examples of transition lines:
A little while later...
That evening,...
After lunch...
She found me...
The next day....
Transition lines can move the reader from place to place
in just a few words.
I think you could use transition lines to separate the times
Mom asks Dad, and then asks you questions. You could
say "Mom found me in my room and asked, "Josh, have
you seen my necklace?"
You could also use a transition line when mom heard the sound
in her room. You could say, A little while later Mom heard a sound
in her room and got up to look or, That evening, Mom heard a sound
in her room and got up to check, or a line like that.
- It would be fun if you ended with a catchy or funny line.
Maybe something like. It turns out that Angel was no angel
afterall. He'd introduced Zero to a life of crime! You could
probably think of something even funnier. Or maybe just
have mom pick up her neckace, so happy to see it that
she bursts out laughing at the two silly cats.
That's all I have for now. You are doing a wonderful job
with your story. It is a great mystery! You should be very
proud of how well you writing!
Warm Spring Wishes,
Lois Szymanski
Joshua really worked hard |
4/04
Dear Mrs. Szymanski,
Here is my revision. Am I close to being done now?
Mom's Lost Necklace
"Oh no! It's gone!" My mom was getting ready for church when she
discovered that her cross necklace was missing. She opened her jewelry box
and her favorite necklace was not in its special place where she always
kept it. She looked everywhere through the house. She looked through her
bathroom but it wasn't there. Then she looked in the closet where she hangs
her clothes. She found the cats in the closet.
Angel and Zero, two naughty little cats, were in the closet. They were
tearing up her dresses. When they saw mom they both ran out of the closet.
Angel had a piece of ribbon in her mouth. Zero had a piece of leather from
mom's shoe in his mouth. Mom wasn't very happy.
That evening mom asked dad if he had seen it and dad said, "No, I did not
touch it " Mom was sad.
Mom saw me playing with my dog, Poochie, and asked, "Joshua, have you seen
my necklace?" After lunch mom asked my brother, "Jared, have you seen
it?" Both of us told mom that we hadn't seen it. Mom was very sad now.
Could it be that a bird flew in the window and took it because it was not
anywhere to be found. The necklace was very special because her mom gave it
to her when she came home from a trip to Paris.
A little while later mom heard a sound in her room and she wondered what it
was. It sounded like a bell. She wondered where the sound came from. She
found Angel, the cat, under her bed. When she looked, she saw something
shiny. Then she saw the necklace! At last she knew who the culprit was! It
was Angel, who was no angel after all! Then she found Zero who was looking
very guilty. Mom was very happy and put her necklace in a safe place where
Angel and Zero could not reach it.
Mom was so happy that she treated all of us to some ice cream at Friendly's.
Your friend,
Joshua Messick
4/06
Joshua,
Wow! Your story is wonderful. Yes! You are almost finished!
There are just a few little things to help you finish up.
When you write your story amd then do second or even a third draft you
are usually rewriting. Next, you edit. That is when you go through and
pick sentences or scenes you want to change a little. Now you
are in the last stage, polishing. To polish your story, you only
fix a few little things, and I could only find a few in this story.
Whenever you say my mom, or my dad you do not use an uppercase letter.
But if you just say Mom or Dad, using it instead of their name, you use
and uppercase letter. Think of it this way. If you could take out the
word mom, or dad and put in their name instead and the story still
sounds right, it should start with an uppercase letter. If you look
through your story you will see a few of the words mom and dad that need
to be Mom or Dad.
The only other thing I would change is in the fourth paragraph. Just to
keep your reader from getting confused about which mom is which, you
might say "The necklace was very special because Grandmother gave it to
mom when she came home from a trip to Paris."
Congratulations! I can't think of anything else to fix! You have done
a beautiful job on your story! Have you ever thought about becoming a
writer!
All my best wishes to you!
Your Friend,
Lois Szymanski
Joshua revised and edited his story |
4/09
Dear Mrs. Szymanski,
Here is my next revision. Am I finished now?
Mom's Lost Necklace
"Oh no! It's gone!" My mom was getting ready for church when she
discovered that her cross necklace was missing. She opened her jewelry box
and her favorite necklace was not in its special place where she always
kept it. She looked everywhere through the house. She looked through her
bathroom but it wasn't there. Then she looked in the closet where she hangs
her clothes. She found the cats in the closet.
Angel and Zero, two naughty little cats, were in the closet. They were
tearing up her dresses. When they saw mom they both ran out of the closet.
Angel had a piece of ribbon in her mouth. Zero had a piece of leather from
mom's shoe in his mouth. Mom wasn't very happy.
That evening mom asked dad if he had seen it and dad said, "No, I did not
touch it " mom was sad.
Mom saw me playing with my dog, Poochie, and asked, "Joshua, have you seen
my necklace?" After lunch mom asked my brother, "Jared, have you seen
it?" Both of us told mom that we hadn't seen it. Mom was very sad now.
Could it be that a bird flew in the window and took it because it was not
anywhere to be found? The necklace was very special because grandmother gave
it to her when she came home from a trip to Paris.
A little while later mom heard a sound in her room and she wondered what it
was. It sounded like a bell. She wondered where the sound came from. She
found Angel, the cat, under her bed. When she looked, she saw something
shiny. Then she saw the necklace! At last she knew who the culprit was! It
was Angel, who was no angel after all! Then she found Zero who was looking
very guilty. Mom was very happy and put her necklace in a safe place where
Angel and Zero could not reach it. Mom was so happy she took us to
Friendly's for some ice cream.
Your friend,
Joshua Messick
4/11/01
Joshua,
You've created a beautfully written story.
I am honored that I was able to be a part,
watching your story grow through all the rewrites!
There is just one tiny thing you need to do.
Everytime you mention Mom or Dad, make them
begin with an uppercase letter. Only that one
tiny thing and you are complete. Wonderful!
Congratulations on finishing your story!
I am looking forward to seeing you in May!
:>)
Your Friend,
Lois Szymanski
Back